Costs Decision

After a three week trial, the Jury returned to Alan’s client a verdict of $65,000.00 in general damages and $175,000.00 in income loss, and found the plaintiff 30% contributorily negligent for the collision. Ultimately, the plaintiff was awarded $168,000.00 gross of the deductible. The plaintiff offered to settle the action prior to trial for $170,000.00. The defendant offered to settle prior to trial for $5,000.00 and, 19 days prior to trial, offered to settle for $35,000.00. The plaintiff beat the defendant’s offer to settle, but despite the ‘near miss’, did not beat her own offer to settle. The plaintiff was awarded partial indemnity costs of $145,000.00 plus disbursements of $85,000.00.

Click here to read the decision


Contact us now with respect to your possible personal injury case.



All decisions are recent trial and appeal decisions with Alan Clausi, except where noted as other case summaries. Alan is determined to fight for your rights!

Al's latest rulings and decisions.

Contact Alan

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.